NIST-09 (Wave Front)

Commonly used for testing adaptive refinement algorithms is Poisson’s equation with a solution that has a steep wave front in the interior of the domain.

Model problem

Equation solved: Poisson equation

(1)-\Delta u - f = 0.

Domain of interest: Unit Square (0, 1)^2

Boundary conditions: Dirichlet, given by exact solution.

Exact solution

u(x, y) = tan^{-1}(\alpha (r - r_{0}))

where r = \sqrt{(x - x_{loc})^{2} + (y - y_{loc})^{2}}, (x_{loc}, y_{loc}) is the center of the circular wave front, r_{0} is the distance from the wave front to the center of the circle, and \alpha gives the steepness of the wave front.

Material parameters

This benchmark has four different versions, we use the global variable PARAM (below) to switch among them.

int PARAM = 3;     // PARAM determines which parameter values you wish to use
                   // for the steepness and location of the wave front.
                   //  | name       | ALPHA | X_LOC | Y_LOC | R_ZERO
                   // 0: mild         20      -0.05   -0.05    0.7
                   // 1: steep        1000    -0.05   -0.05    0.7
                   // 2: asymmetric   1000     1.5     0.25    0.92
                   // 3: well         50       0.5     0.5     0.25

Sample solution

Solution for \alpha = 50, (x_{loc}, y_{loc}) = (0.5, 0.5), and r_{0} = 0.25:

Solution.

Comparison of h-FEM (p=1), h-FEM (p=2) and hp-FEM with anisotropic refinements

Final mesh (h-FEM, p=1, anisotropic refinements):

Final mesh.

Final mesh (h-FEM, p=2, anisotropic refinements):

Final mesh.

Final mesh (hp-FEM, h-anisotropic refinements):

Final mesh.

DOF convergence graphs:

DOF convergence graph.

CPU convergence graphs:

CPU convergence graph.

hp-FEM with iso, h-aniso and hp-aniso refinements

Final mesh (hp-FEM, isotropic refinements):

Final mesh.

Final mesh (hp-FEM, h-anisotropic refinements):

Final mesh.

Final mesh (hp-FEM, hp-anisotropic refinements):

Final mesh.

DOF convergence graphs:

DOF convergence graph.

CPU convergence graphs:

CPU convergence graph.